top of page
Driving with Confidence on the road.
Amy Kleithermes

The Best Insurance Rates.

The Friendliest Local Insurance Agent. The Best Claims Support.

White Background Strip

Welcome to Insurance with Amy.

Insurance coverage needs vary, but the ONE thing everyone needs is a friendly, knowledgeable agent to guide you to the right coverage at the best rate; and to support you down the road!

As your local insurance broker, we shop multiple insurance companies for the best rates and coverages to help protect your hard-earned assets. As an independent agent we work for YOU, not an insurance company. We offer sound advice and give you the direction you need to find the best insurance policies and coverages. 

The biggest Insurance with Amy difference: We’re here when you need us. From rate shopping to claims, and everything in between. You’re never stuck with an 800 number, or a long wait for a customer service representative. You call. We answer. 

That’s the real Insurance with Amy difference. Better service. Lower rates.

White Background Strip

Best Insurance Coverages

Mother getting homeowners insurance quote.

Homeowner’s Insurance

Woman confident with Car Insurance

Car Insurance

Image by Daniel Tausis

Fire & Flood Insurance

Man working confidently with Business Insurance

Business Insurance

Advantages of an Insurance Broker


At Insurance with Amy, we’re an insurance broker. This means we’re not tied to any one insurance company. We can truly find you the best coverage at the best rate – with no ties to a particular company. This means better insurance rates for you. 

You do not pay us a penny. We’re paid by the insurance company, whichever offer you decide to go with. 

We invite you to shop around. We promise you’ll be hard pressed to find any better rates, and we’re confident you’ll never find better customer service than right here at Insurance with Amy!

White background strip

The only thing we love more than our customers is watching them save money! 

See why our happy customers love working with us as their insurance broker!

Tell us your 5-Star Insurance with Amy Story! 

A World of Insurance Coverage Right in Your Backyard

We provide the best rates nationwide, right here in Pacific, MO. We’d love to meet you sometime – stop in to see us anytime!

We’re here when you need us! Ask about our multi-line insurance discounts!

What are your insurance needs?

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page